Name: Irresistible 3-Cheese Potato Pie - Creamy Bliss in Every Bite
Prep time: 20 min
Cook time: 1 h 5 min
Total time: 1 h 25 min
Cuisine: American
Ingredients: 2 lbs Yukon Gold potatoes, thinly sliced; 2 cups heavy cream; 1½ cups shredded mozzarella cheese; 1 cup shredded sharp cheddar cheese; ½ cup grated Parmesan cheese; 2 cloves garlic, minced; 2 tbsp unsalted butter; 1 tsp salt; ½ tsp black pepper; ½ tsp dried thyme (optional); Fresh chopped chives (for garnish)

Jump to Recipe

Oh, do I have a recipe for you! When the holidays roll around or I just need that warm, cozy feeling on a chilly night, this Creamy Cheese Potato Pie is my go-to. It’s like a hug in baking dish form—golden layers of tender Yukon Gold potatoes swimming in garlicky cream and bubbling cheese. I swear, the smell alone will have everyone crowding into the kitchen. After years of testing (and many, many cheesy potato experiments), I’ve found the perfect balance—creamy without being heavy, cheesy without overwhelming the potatoes. Pro tip: don’t skimp on letting it rest before serving—those last 10 minutes make all the difference between a messy slice and perfect, creamy layers standing tall on your fork.

Why You’ll Love This Creamy Cheese Potato Pie

Trust me, this isn’t just another potato dish—it’s the kind of recipe that disappears fast at potlucks and has everyone asking for seconds. Here’s why it’s a winner:

Creamy dreaminess: The heavy cream and three-cheese combo creates layers that melt in your mouth—no dry potatoes here!
Golden perfection: That crispy Parmesan top? It’s the satisfying crunch you didn’t know you needed.
Easy prep: Just slice, layer, and bake—no fancy techniques required.
Crowd-pleaser magic: Works for holiday dinners or Tuesday nights when you need comfort food fast.

My family fights over the corner pieces—that’s how good it is.

Ingredients for Creamy Cheese Potato Pie

Here’s everything you’ll need to make this cheesy masterpiece (and yes, every single ingredient matters!):

2 lbs Yukon Gold potatoes – thinly sliced (about 1/8-inch thick – trust me, uniform slices mean even cooking)
2 cups heavy cream – the rich foundation of our sauce
1½ cups shredded mozzarella – for that glorious stretchy cheese pull
1 cup shredded sharp cheddar – adds a nice tang to balance the cream
½ cup grated Parmesan – our golden, crispy crown
2 cloves garlic – minced fine (none of that jarred stuff!)
2 tbsp unsalted butter – helps control the saltiness
1 tsp salt + ½ tsp black pepper – basics done right
½ tsp dried thyme (optional) – my secret flavor booster
Fresh chives – because everything’s better with a green confetti finish

See? Simple ingredients, extraordinary results – that’s my cooking philosophy!

Equipment You’ll Need

Gather these kitchen essentials—nothing fancy, just the right tools to make magic happen:

Sharp knife (or mandoline if you’re feeling fancy—watch those fingers!)
Medium saucepan for that garlicky cream mixture
9×13 baking dish—the perfect stage for our cheesy layers
Foil to trap steam and prevent premature browning

That’s it! No special gadgets required—just good old-fashioned baking love.

How to Make Creamy Cheese Potato Pie

Okay, let’s get to the fun part—turning these simple ingredients into golden, cheesy perfection! Follow these steps, and you’ll have the most comforting potato pie ready in no time.

Step 1: Prep the Potatoes and Cream Mixture

First things first—preheat that oven to 375°F (190°C). While it’s heating up, grab your potatoes and slice them about 1/8-inch thick. Pro tip: If you’re using a mandoline, watch those fingertips! Uneven slices mean uneven cooking, and we want every bite perfect.

Now, melt your butter in a saucepan over medium heat and toss in the minced garlic. Cook just until fragrant—about 30 seconds—then pour in the heavy cream. Add the salt, pepper, and thyme (if using), and warm it gently. Whatever you do, don’t let it boil! We’re just taking the chill off and letting those flavors mingle.

Step 2: Layer the Creamy Cheese Potato Pie

Time to build those dreamy layers! Grease your baking dish well—trust me, you don’t want cheesy potatoes sticking. Start with a layer of potato slices, slightly overlapping like shingles. Drizzle about 1/3 of the cream mixture over them, then sprinkle with mozzarella and cheddar. Repeat this twice more, finishing with a generous blanket of Parmesan on top. The cheese is like the glue holding all this deliciousness together!

Step 3: Bake to Perfection

Cover the dish tightly with foil—this helps the potatoes steam and get tender. Bake for 40 minutes, then remove the foil. This is when the magic happens! Bake another 20-25 minutes until the top is golden brown and bubbly, and the potatoes are fork-tender. The smell will be incredible!

Here’s the hardest part: let it rest for 10-15 minutes before slicing. I know it’s tempting to dive right in, but this waiting time lets the layers set so you get perfect slices instead of a cheesy landslide. Your patience will be rewarded!

Tips for the Best Creamy Cheese Potato Pie

Want to take your potato pie from good to “can I get the recipe?” levels? Here are my hard-earned secrets:

Slice smart: Use a mandoline or sharp knife for uniform potato slices—thick chunks won’t cook evenly, and paper-thin slices disappear into mush.
Patience pays: That 15-minute rest isn’t optional! It lets the creamy layers set so your slices hold their shape beautifully.
Fresh garnishes: Sprinkle chopped chives right before serving—their bright pop cuts through the richness and makes it look restaurant-worthy.

Oh, and if your cheese browns too fast, just tent with foil—no one wants burnt Parmesan!

Variations for Your Creamy Cheese Potato Pie

Once you’ve mastered the classic version, try these fun twists—I’ve tested them all, and each brings something special to the table:

Bacon lover’s dream: Toss in crispy bacon bits between layers—the smoky saltiness cuts through the cream beautifully.
Caramelized onion upgrade: Add a layer of sweet, golden onions for extra depth (my husband’s favorite version).
Smoky kick: Swap thyme for smoked paprika—just ¼ teaspoon gives it a warm, campfire vibe.

Feel free to play—that’s how the best family recipes are born!

Serving Suggestions for Creamy Cheese Potato Pie

This pie is the ultimate team player at any table! For holidays, I love pairing it with rosemary-roasted chicken or honey-glazed ham—the creamy potatoes balance those bold flavors perfectly. Weeknight dinner? Try it alongside a crisp green salad to cut through the richness. Oh, and don’t forget the crusty bread for soaking up every last bit of that cheesy sauce!

Storage and Reheating

Got leftovers? Lucky you! Cover the pie tightly with foil or transfer slices to an airtight container—it’ll keep beautifully in the fridge for up to 3 days. When you’re ready for round two, reheat in a 350°F oven until warmed through (about 15-20 minutes). The microwave works in a pinch, but trust me, the oven brings back that crispy top and creamy texture best. Pro tip: sprinkle a little extra cheese before reheating for that fresh-baked magic!

Nutritional Information

Here’s the scoop on what’s in each comforting serving (based on 6 portions): about 480 calories, with 18g protein and 4g fiber from those golden potatoes. Remember, these are just estimates—your exact numbers will dance a bit depending on cheese brands and potato sizes. But let’s be real—when something tastes this good, sometimes the best nutrition is joy!

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use russet potatoes instead of Yukon Golds?
You can, but the texture will be different. Russets are starchier and absorb more liquid—your pie might turn out drier. If you must substitute, cut the bake time by 5-10 minutes and check often. Personally? I’d run to the store for Yukon Golds—their buttery texture and thin skins make all the difference!

How do I prevent the cream from curdling?
The key is low and slow! Don’t boil the cream mixture—just warm it gently until steam rises. Also, make sure your dairy isn’t expired (I’ve learned this the hard way). If you see tiny lumps while baking, don’t panic—the cheese will camouflage them!

Can I make this ahead of time?
Absolutely! Assemble everything up to the baking step, cover tightly, and refrigerate overnight. Just add 5-10 minutes to the bake time since it’s going in cold. Pro tip: Let it sit at room temp for 30 minutes first—this prevents thermal shock to your baking dish.

Why do my potatoes turn gray?
That’s oxidation—totally harmless but not pretty! To prevent it, keep sliced potatoes in cold water until ready to use (just pat them dry before layering). A splash of lemon juice in the water helps too—the acid stops the discoloration without affecting flavor.

Can I freeze leftovers?
Technically yes, but the texture suffers—potatoes get mealy when frozen and thawed. If you must, freeze individual portions and reheat in the oven (not microwave) to minimize sogginess. Better yet? Share with neighbors—this pie tastes best fresh!

Share Your Creamy Cheese Potato Pie Experience

Did you try this recipe? I’d love to hear how it turned out for you! Leave a comment with your favorite variation, snap a photo of that golden crust, or tell me who fought over the last bite at your table. These shared moments are what make cooking so special—every kitchen tells its own delicious story!

Irresistible 3-Cheese Potato Pie – Creamy Bliss in Every Bite